| 1864 |
| Jackson, William Taylor |
| Steele, Emma Neidig |
| 1865 |
| Shuey, Jacob Augustus |
| 1868 |
| Emerson, Mary Beam |
| Harden, Amelia Grove |
| 1869 |
| Cook, Elnora A. |
| Overholser, Joseph B. |
| Page, Homer R. |
| 1870 |
| Washburn, Martha Allison |
| 1871 |
| Collier, Alfred D. |
| 1872 |
| Bookwalter, Lewis |
| Custer, William Henry |
| Drury, Augustus Waldo |
| Drury, Marion Richardson |
| Fry, Francis Rhinehart |
| Kephart, Sallie Perry |
| Williams, Lucy Strother |
| Swain, Anna Shuey |
| Light, Sarah Surran |
| Williams, Robert Erwin |
| 1873 |
| Bauder, Thomas Jefferson |
| Booth, Milo |
| Bowman, Henry G. |
| McHose, Eva Drury |
| Light, Enoch Faber |
| Riggs, William Kendrick |
| Sheak, Henry |
| Surran, John Wesley |
| 1874 |
| Arble, William Bower |
| Conn, Luther M. |
| Kephart, Cyrus Jeffries |
| Marshall, Alvin Lyman |
| Washburn, Francis Marion |
| 1875 |
| Albert, John Henry |
| Gambrel, Mildred |
| Hopwood, Mary Louise |
| 1876 |
| Beal, Albert Milton |
| Beatty, William Irons |
| Drury, Sophia Bookwalter |
| Peffley, Mary Clarissa Hedges |
| Hopwood, Jeannette Belle |
| Kauffman, William Henry |
| Smith, Frank S. |
| 1877 |
| Bookwalter, Joseph |
| Burkdol, Arsemus Richmond |
| Ham, William Jasper |
| Horn, John Martin |
| Johnson, Josephine |
| McAlvin, Sarah Jane |
| Moore, John Augustus |
| Neidig, Abram Hershey |
| Runkle, Urias D. |
| Shumaker, Australia Patterson |
| Beatty, Catherine Patterson |
| Hopwood, Almina Woolridge |
| 1878 |
| Baumgardner, John Wesley |
| Moore, Arthur Melbourne |
| 1879 |
| Klinefelter, William Henry |
| Linderman, Walter LeRoy |
| Miller, Daniel |
| Miller, Eliza Moore |
| Davis, Emma Patton |
| 1880 |
| DeMoss, William Otterbein |
| Albert, Louisa Halverson |
| Kretsinger, Ernest Otterbein |
| Mathewson, George D. |
| Ridenour, Eli H. |
| Robertson, James Wesley |
| 1881 |
| Miller, Adeline Dickman |
| Drury, John Lawrence |
| Drury, Mary Ellen Horn |
| Miller, George McAnelly |
| Wilson, Alice Singley |
| Wilson, Robert Rush |
| 1882 |
| Smith, Walter Clarence |
| Studebaker, Thomas Henderson |
| 1883 |
| Weller, Emma Jane Howard |
| Johnson, Willis Eaton |
| 1884 |
| Albert, Isaiah L. |
| Russell, Kate Adell Coates |
| Folkmar, Daniel |
| Browne, Frank J. |
| Carlton, Vivian Albert |
| Leffler, John F. |
| Leffler, Anna Maiden |
| Schell, Charles Fremont |
| Swain, Richard LaRue |
| 1886 |
| Sears, Lucy Blinn |
| Brooke, Charles Morgan |
| Hendricks, John P. |
| Lowe, Simeon Jethro |
| Dick, Cora Middlekauff |
| Merritt, James A. |
| Wonser, Josephine Patterson |
| Smith, Eugene Riley |
| Timmons, Cyrus Holland |
| 1887 |
| Smith, Daisy Gallion |
| Greenlee, Mary Emma |
| Miller, Myrtle Jarvis |
| Mundhenk, Charles Lincoln |
| Runkle, Jesse A. |
| Barnes, Minnie Whitten |
| 1888 |
| Bennett, Charles E. |
| Bonebrake, Peter O. |
| Austin, Esther Butler |
| Keezel, Clara Cozad |
| Richie, Elnora Dickman |
| Filkins, Daniel G. |
| Rogers, Gazelle Holstead |
| Keister, Lawrence |
| Roop, Emma May Kephart |
| Lichtenwalter, E. Geneve |
| Louthan, Mary T. |
| Patterson, Alvin H. |
| Slessor, Albert Edward |
| Rebok, Edna Thompson |
| Ward, Henry Winfield |
| Wilcox, Thomas Dwight |
| Zumbro, William M. |
| 1889 |
| Abrams, Eugene D. |
| Baker, Charles D. |
| Beatty, Squire Trevelyn |
| Buchner, Edward Franklin |
| Chitty, Oliver Benjamin |
| Coe, Horace C. |
| Cokely, Benjamin F. |
| Winter, Etta Fulcomer |
| Krohn, William Oterbein |
| Ward, John Albert |
| 1890 |
| Gary, Simon Peter |
| George, Jeremiah S. |
| Hettler, Franz Seigel |
| Ingham, Clarence Ward |
| John, Lulu Maude Kephart |
| Kolmos, Jesse Jessen |
| Harper, Susie Lichtenwalter Riggs |
| Little, William Grant |
| Runkle, May Middlekauff |
| Runkle, Erwin William |
| Schell, William Elias |
| Shatto, Charles Rollins |
| Smith, William Avery |
| Statton, Arthur Biggs |
| Stauffer, Emma |
| Stouffer, Frank E. |
| Stouffer, Samuel Marcelius |
| Warren, Willis Austin |
| Watts, Roderick Freeman |
| 1891 |
| Osborn, Anna Brabham |
| Burtner, Newton Weldon |
| Cronk, Nelson P. |
| Everett, Howard H. |
| Trueblood, Jennie Fearer |
| Fearer, William Potter |
| Fee, William E. |
| Fix, Elmer F. |
| Fix, Fannie Heistand |
| Green Hiram O. |
| Harper, William Otterbein |
| Loos, Lloyd Fisher |
| Spencer, Clark D. |
| 1892 |
| Barnell, William B. |
| Brewbaker, Charles W. |
| Cain, Isaac N. |
| Wilkins, Annetta Dickman |
| Dennis, Mary Pitman Donaldson |
| Humphrey, Addie Ingersoll |
| Ross, Nellie Irons |
| Kepler, Richard P. |
| Kepler, Malvern H. |
| Scutt, Clara Mason |
| Cain, Mary Mutch |
| Ross, Emma Maynard |
| Allen, Belle Schelling |
| Jones, Louise Shambaugh |
| Lowry, Harriet Tyner |
| 1893 |
| Gehman, Lewis H. |
| Franks, Anna Hild |
| Humphrey, Howard M. |
| Jones, Ferdinand W. |
| Main, Amos S. |
| Richards, Ida |
| Spencer, Mary B. |
| Stratton, W.D. |
| Wheelwright, Sidney Alcott |
| 1894 |
| Beardsley, Frank Greenville |
| Guyer, Ulysses Samuel |
| Hull, J.F. |
| Kaufman, Frank E. |
| Masters, Mark |
| Maker, L.E. |
| McClain, Joseph H. |
| Purdy, Richard L. |
| Slattery, Henry Eugene |
| Statton, Lola Adams |
| 1895 |
| Brooke, Franklin E. |
| Coddington, James Keel |
| Long, Samuel Erwin |
| Peterson, Charles F. |
| Porter, G. Ellis |
| Sanders, James C. |
| 1896 |
| Bookwalter, Alfred Guitner |
| Long, Frank K. |
| 1897 |
| Baumgartner, Milton M. |
| Drury, Philo Walker |
| Foster, John Eldon |
| Porter, George Wesley |
| Runkle, Herman A. |
| Baumgartner, Lucie Smith |
| Ward, Elizabeth Bessie Schoolcraft |
| Ward, Edwin Beecher |
| 1898 |
| Berger, Edward B. |
| Burtner, Ethel Bookwalter |
| Buck, Frank E. |
| Coddington, John Watt |
| Irons, James W. |
| Jenks, Clarence A. |
| Lichty, John N. |
| Speaker, Alvin L. |
| Ward, Charles Fry |
| Williams, Olive |
| Williams, Blanche |
| Stover, Louise Wolpert |
| 1899 |
| Field, Frank E. |
| Hammitt, Leon L. |
| Holstead, Grace |
| Locke, Charles E. |
| Mathern, Albert |
| Mericle, Clarence |
| 1900 |
| Bear, Wilson Grant |
| Benson, Ernest Allen |
| Cunningham, Nettie |
| Harrison, William Johnston |
| Soth, Blanche Hutchinson |
| Jorgensen, Theodore |
| Drury, Julia Overholser |
| Runkle, Mildred Smith |
| Ward, Grace Wolpert |
| Wyand, Samuel Snyder |
| 1901 |
| Berger, Charles Emmett |
| Bookwalter, Grace |
| Brenner, William Arthur |
| Coddington, Harry |
| Donat, Walter Scott |
| Harrigan, James Corneal |
| Jackson, George Brown |
| Smith, Mabel |
| Stouffer, Wesley Rhinehart |
| Talbot, Lois |
| Thompson, Samuel |
| Trindle, John Robert |
| Ward, Arthur Allen |
| Yaggy, Jacob Henry |
| 1902 |
| Southard, Rilla Aiken |
| Ward, Alice Bookwalter |
| Cramer, Hiram Walter |
| Adams, Nellie Cronk |
| Hix, Ralph Mason |
| Morton, Claude Henry |
| Skrable, Joseph Martin |
| Underwood, Joseph Harding |
| 1903 |
| Aiken, Angie |
| Doty, Earl Isaac |
| Gageby, Frank A. |
| Larsen, August Cornelius |
| McAnelly, Jefferson Roy |
| Rebok, Lona |
| Roe, Barnett Freeman |
| Shambaugh, John Jacob |
| Stinger, Carl Blinn |
| Thomas, Gertrude May |
| Taylor, Ernest Clayton |
| 1904 |
| McClaskey, Edith Camery |
| Clark, Ethelbert Fletcher |
| Elliott, Clarence H. |
| Emerson, Glenn Wilford |
| Ennis, Charles Wilbur |
| Ferris, Emery Nelson |
| Hedges, Charles Theodore |
| Kephart, Adam Perry |
| Miller, Harland Travy |
| Riggs, Lee Sanford |
| Riggs, Emma E. |
| Soth, Florence |
| Stauffer, Clyde Homer |
| Sullivan, William Charles |
| 1905 |
| Ageton, Maud |
| Miller, Jane Benson |
| Cotton, George H. |
| Drury, Luther |
| Giger, Herbert Paul |
| Jenks, Georgianna |
| Kremer, Charles Merwin |
| McDonald, David James |
| Mericle, John Franklin |
| Maxfield, Glenmore Edward |
| 1906 |
| Crenshaw, Benjamin Franklin |
| Curtis, Edith |
| Fee, Knight E. |
| Foster, Charles Eldon |
| Hart, William Walace |
| Owen, William Beam |
| Shambaugh, Scott |
| 1907 |
| Ball, Grace Lauretta |
| Benson, Laura May |
| Benson, Ross Danforth |
| Fee, Clara May |
| Jarvis, Frank |
| Lee, Mary Helen |
| Lee, George Ernest |
| Speaker, Lloyd Fosler |
| Walden, Mary Elizabeth Trussell |
| Wright, Mabel |
| Walden, Lloyd Frank |
| 1908 |
| Caldwell, Rebecca Ellen |
| Forney, Earl B. |
| Galt, Truman Fontanelle |
| Jenks, Jessie |
| Soth, Mabel Kephart |
| Mericle, Charles L. |
| Oakes, Fred T. Mayer |
| Soth, M. Ray |
| 1909 |
| Bear, Lloyd E. |
| Bishop, Alva Otto |
| Chapman, George E. |
| Doty, Elizabeth Talbot |
| Geil, Charles H. |
| Hagerman, Arthur James |
| Lewis, Mabel |
| Lee, Hugh B. |
| Smith, Alta |
| Smith, Olga |
| Thomas, Clyde Earl |
| Violet, Dewey Cecil |
| Youngman, Maude |
| 1910 |
| Brooke, Boone Winthrop |
| Benson, Florence |
| Browne, Mabel Curtis |
| Johnson, Ralph Wilkinson |
| Jackson, LeeR. |
| Lee, Edith Maud |
| Meyers, Ada Mary |
| Rebok, Robert |
| Riggs, Fred |
| Richards, Carlton M. |
| Speaker, Earl E. |
| Studebaker, John Ward |
| Studebaker, Claude H. |
| St. Clair, Floyd Pitner |
| Talbot, Ruth |
| Westfall, Floyd Sylvanus |