VOLUME.
XVIII. JANUARY, 1902. No. 1.
EARLY SOCIAL AND RELIGIOUS EXPERIMENTS IN
IOWA.
An attempt to give a broad general view of the early
social and religious experiments in Iowa is of necessity
hampered by the deplorable lack of available original sources.
The genesis of any period is usually shrouded in mystery, and
although the historian sometimes finds letters, diaries, or
documents of pertinent importance, yet he must, in the main,
depend upon autobiographies, reminiscences, and contemporary
newspapers. Realizing fully the inadequacy and uncertainty of
this kind of material, we are, nevertheless, compelled to
admit that it gives us practically the only authentic
information that we have. This crude product, uncertain as it
is, if subjected to a searching critical inspection, will yet
yield much that will be of direct value. Bearing this in mind
I have rejected all secondary histories and culled my material
only from the most available original sources. The
Annals of Iowa
and the HISTORICAL RECORD, the
publications of the State Historical Society, are both so
replete with sketches from the pens of old settlers, that they
have been very largely relied upon; but extended use has also
been-made of autobiographies, documentary material and
monographs on special subjects. It has been my purpose to give
as fully as the limits of this brief essay would allow, some
of the more important historical movements which have
distinguished the first thirty years of the settlement of
Iowa.
I. Introduction
The continuous westward march of civilization, which
has been so manifest throughout the ages of the past, received
its most striking exemplification in the New World. America
quietly received its priceless heritage from Europe, and then
proceeded in its own way to work out a distinctive American
development, which completely harmonized the new environment
and the growing American individuality.
This development was not, however, the result of static
or fixed conditions, but, as a system, was largely influenced
by the rapid expansion of the country. From a little cluster
of settlements along the shores of the Atlantic, it spread
first over into the Northwest Territory and then across the
Mississippi into the broad plains of the great West. In each
of the successive stages of this growth the changed conditions
were met by a transplanted, rather than by a direct
germinative social life.
The hardy western pioneer was imbued with the inborn
spirit of freedom and justice, while, at the same time, he was
unhampered by the conventional restraints of civilization. He
was thus enabled to develop a system adapted to his peculiar
surroundings, yet containing those broad principles which, by
this very process of expansion and evolution, have become
fundamental to our institutions. In the words of Professor
Turner: "American social development has been continually
beginning over again on the frontier. This perennial rebirth,
this fluidity of American life, this expansion westward with
its new opportunities, its continuous touch with the
simplicity of primitive society, furnish the forces dominating
American character. The true point of view in the history of
this nation is not the Atlantic coast, it is the great West
.....Thus the advance of the frontier has meant a steady
movement away from the influences of Europe, a steady growth
of independence on American lines. And to study this advance,
the man who grew up under these conditions, and the political,
economic, and social results of it, is to study the really
American part of our history." *
Upon the very threshold of this great West stood the
beautiful land of Iowa - a land whose beauty and potential
wealth rivaled the glories of any El Dorado and outshone the
fabled riches of India and the far East. It was here that the
on-going column started on its great mission; and it was here
that the sturdy pioneer founded a home for himself, and began
the work which shaped the destiny of a great people. Within
thirty years from the time the first permanent white settler
built his cabin upon the western shore of the great Father of
Waters, the broad expanse from the Mississippi to the Missouri
had become a populous, prospering state, well advanced in the
most refined type of civilization.
The development during this brief but comprehensive
period presents a picture of unusual attractiveness. Yet
including, as it does, a field as broad and diverse as human
life itself; any attempt to reproduce this picture by detached
snapshots would only lead to obscurity and confusion as
inexplicable as that which envelops the traveler lost in the
labyrinthine mazes of a Moorish palace. Any adequate treatment
of the subject, therefore must deal with it broadly, regarding
the specific events only as parts of the unified whole and
simply as amplifications of the central dominating idea. As an
eminent historian has said, - "the supreme value of history
depends upon the truthfulness with which it traces the great
currents of human life, rather than upon its ability to
explain why some particular eddy or ripple disturbed the
surface of the stream at a given point." **
The whole course of development during these early
periods of frontier life was, of course, mainly tentative and
experimental. The principle that the family is very intimately
connected with the origin of all government, is so well
recognized that it need cause no surprise when we apply it to
frontier settlements. The family, being inherently a natural
organization, formed the basis for a further growth along
institutional lines. It shaped the social life and spirit of
the day, and from it emanated the religious faith and
practices of the people Thus it is the social and religious
activities, combined in one conception of organic social
evolution, that forms the foundation for a better
understanding of more advanced institutions. It is our
purpose, therefore, to treat of the settlement and growth of
Iowa from 1830 to 1860, with special reference to their
essential relation to the main historical movements that have
exerted such a potent influence in moulding the distinctive
character of this great commonwealth.
II.
In many respects the first settlement in any region is
usually of great importance as indicating the most probable
line of development. It is the source from which other
settlements are formed, and from it radiates the influences
that are to mould the character of the surrounding country.
Strange as it may seem, this was only in a very limited sense
true in Iowa. The Mississippi River was a broad highway that
furnished comparatively easy access to all points upon the
border, and by thus segregating interests prevented the
formation of a single
distributing point.
Add to this the fact that the first settlement was
distinctively a mining community, and its peculiar situation
is even more apparent. A detailed consideration of the first
attempts at settlement will illustrate this point.
The first settlement in what is now Iowa was made by
Julien Dubuque. On the twenty-second of September, 1788, he
purchased from the Sac and Fox Indians a tract of land on the
west side of the Mississippi River, and soon after settling
there, he opened up and began to work the valuable deposits of
lead upon his land. Dubuque had spent most of his life among
the Indians, knew their language and their customs, and was
almost one of their number.
The second settlement was that of Lewis Honari at
Montrose on the Mississippi, about ten miles above the mouth
of the Des Moines River. The country then belonged to Spain,
and on the thirtieth of March, 1799, he secured an official
grant from Zenon Trudeau, the acting governor of Upper
Louisiana, which, besides bestowing other privileges, read as
follows:
" It is permitted to Mr. Louis (Fresson) Honari to
establish himself at the head of the rapids of the river Des
Moines, and his establishment once formed, notice of it shall
be given to the Governor General, in order to obtain from -him
the commission of a space sufficient to give value to said
establishment, and at the same time to render it useful to the
commerce o the peltries of this country; to watch the Indians
and to keep them in fidelity which they owe to his Majesty."
This, however, did not prove permanent, as Honari held
possession only until 1805, when it passed into other hands
and was subsequently entirely abandoned; although long after
some persons who claimed an interest, attempted to revive the
title, the result being the famous Half Breed Tract Cases,
which caused such extended litigation for many years. In 1808,
a third attempt at settlement was made by the erection of Fort
Madison. The Indians regarded this as a violation of the
existing treaty as well as a continual menace to their safety
and freedom of action; and, by persistent and harassing
attacks, soon made the fort untenable, so that it was
abandoned and burned.
The project of Julien Dubuque was more fortunate and
continued to prosper until his death in 1810. After that
unfortunate event, the Indians, although they could not work
the mines to any extent, continued vigilantly to guard them
from encroachment by the whites. The Indians had built a
village on Catfish Creek, a short distance below the mines;
but, in the spring of 1830, as a result of long continued
hostilities, a band of their chiefs was killed by a party of
Sioux. This intelligence so alarmed the Sacs and Foxes that
they precipitately abandoned their village and sought a safer
habitation in the interior. The watchful white settlers upon
the eastern bank soon became aware of this fact and with
natural and pardonable curiosity ventured to cross the river
and inspect the forbidden ]and. Among these were miners from
Galena, who soon discovered the valuable deposits of ore and
began to make preparations to mine and market the product. But
the Indians had not yet sold their lands, and the United
States, desiring to keep faith until that much desired event
could be fully accomplished, undertook to keep all the
settlers off that territory. Captain Zachary Taylor, who was
then in command of the United States troops at the fort at
Prairie du Chien, by a vigorous coup d'etat (so characteristic
of the old warrior and statesman) compelled the miners to
abandon the district and to recross to the other side of the
river.
In 1832, when it became known that the Government had
bought the land, they again began the active operation of the
mines. " They built houses, erected furnaces for smelting, cut
hay, and made every preparation for a winter's work, and
before the first of January there were over two hundred
persons collected about the mines and many valuable lodes had
been discovered, and a large amount of lead manufactured."
Yet even this movement proved to be premature, for the
treaty itself stipulated that the Indians should remain in
sole possession until the first of June, 1833. It seemed
considerable of a hardship to deprive the miners of the fruit
of their labors, but Uncle Sam, feeling in duty bound to abide
by his agreement, politely informed the land immediately.
When at last the long desired haven was opened to
settlers, the miners were chagrined to find that the
government had assumed control of the mineral lands and had
sent an agent to issue permits to work the mines and to see
that the venous other requirements were observed. The
opposition to this policy was so pronounced that the
government was compelled to abandon it, and some thirteen
years later the lands were brought into the market and sold.
During the summer of 1833 the tide of immigration flowed
rapidly into the mining district, and, in the following
winter, a town was laid out. By a vote of the people assembled
in a public meeting, the town was named Dubuque after the
hardy old pioneer, who, so many years before, had discovered
and first operated the rich mineral deposits. The development
from the nucleus thus formed was rapid and spontaneous, and it
was not long before Dubuque became a thriving populous town.
It has seemed best to dwell thus at some length upon the
vicissitudes of the first settlement at Dubuque for several
reasons. In the first place, it formed practically the first
permanent settlement upon Iowa soil, for though there were
several other towns about contemporary in time, the legacy
received from the far-seeing Julien Dubuque gives it a
priority which cannot be overlooked. It also represents the
difficulty which the early settler experienced in gaming
access to the territory, and is fairly typical of man of the
settlements along the river. But most important of all,
Dubuque is unique in that it was formed and developed as a
mining center. Settlers were attracted to Dubuque by its
mineral wealth while the rest of Iowa, being essentially
agricultural, became peopled with those who desired to make
homes for themselves upon its beautiful prairies. As a mining
camp it was more or less under the influence of the proverbial
lawless element and in this regard, as we shall see later,
Dubuque did exercise considerable influence over the early
Iowa communities. It is perhaps fortunate that it did not hold
as prominent a place in the formation of the public character
as its position as the first settlement would seem to warrant.
At any rate, we must consider Dubuque as the exception that
gives vivacity to the rule and treat it merely as a very
important side-light upon the main movement.
III.
What we have characterized as the main movement in the
settlement of Iowa was the tendency of settlers to find homes
for themselves upon the public domain. As the eastern States
became more thickly settled, the desire for larger
opportunities prompted many deserving and ambitious people to
seek an opening in the unknown West. The large majority of
these were farmers, who brought with them not only the most
important implements of their vocation, but also the spirit of
a tiller of the soil. The predominating impulse of the settler
was thus agricultural in its nature, and the broad prairies
gave an added incentive for a full realization of this
purpose. Very early in the
century, and long before the regular settlement began, a few
isolated trading- posts had been established at various points
west of the Mississippi in what was known as the Black Hawk
territory. The several Fur Companies continued to maintain
agencies well into the interior in order to secure the first
chance at the furs and pelts of the Indians and trappers. But
though these were probably the first harbingers of
civilization, they were too uncertain and transitory to exert
any permanent influence or take rank as important
institutions. Besides
these traders there was another class of early arrivals which
were generally known as " squatters" . It seems to be one of
the inborn elements of human nature to possess a fascinating
desire for forbidden fruit. It takes a very strong and
unaccommodating conscience to withstand such allurements, and
often the uncertainty furnishes a too welcome spice for the
monotony of life. The government, in undertaking to keep the
settlers out of Iowa until a certain date, furnished just such
an opportunity for adventurous spirits, and although unusual
vigilance was exercised, it is an undoubted fact that a few
pioneers evaded the careful circumspection of the dragoons and
secured early homes on the frontier. It is no more than just
to say, however, that these were comparatively few, and that
the great mass of the settlers were meritorious and law
abiding citizens, who made their claims upon Iowa soil only
after it was regularly opened for settlement.
With the exception, then, of the trader and the
"squatter," there were no white settlers in the territory
until June first, 1833, when the land was nominally, though
not legally, thrown open to all comers. On that date the
Indian title was extinguished and the active military
restraints of the government ceased. Claims were immediately
taken at the most advantageous points along the river. Many of
these new comers hailed from Illinois, having come directly
across the river. Most of them, however, came from the East,
generally by a long and tedious journey down the Ohio and up
the Mississippi. It is no wonder, therefore, that they stopped
at the first convenient landing-place, and, in this way,
unintentionally built up the towns on the lower Mississippi
much more rapidly than those farther up the river.
Burlington was the first town to be regularly laid out,
the original plat being surveyed in November and December
1833. Its early prominence was due in part to its having
previously been an Indian trading-post "with numerous old
trading houses, boat houses, and a number of Indian graves
along the bank of the river" and in part to its accessibility
as a landing place. About the same time claims were made near
Fort Madison, although the town was not platted until 1835. In
1836, as a result of a meeting of settlers at the home of
Colonel George Davenport at Rock Island, a town was surveyed
and named Davenport in honor of the colonel, who, besides
being one of the early settlers in the region, was also one of
the prime movers in the new enterprise. In 1837 the embryo
town of Keokuk was formally laid out in what had been the
potato patch of one of the early settlers.
The difficulties of travel made immigration seem
comparatively slow for the first few years. The first comers
usually settled near the river and, as the population
increased, the less desirable lands were taken up or the
settler moved a little farther from the river before selecting
the site for his cabin. The best locations were thus rapidly
acquired, and it is evident from the dates at which the towns
were laid out that the formation of a town plat was considered
one of the first requirements of a growing community. The
towns which were thus favorably located grew rapidly.
There were a great many other towns laid out in the hope
that they might become county seats, or great emporiums which
would receive the trade of the whole country; but too often
these fond hopes were realized only in the dreams of the
deluded speculator. The city of Rockingham is a case in point,
and is fairly typical of many another bursted bubble. It was
settled in the fall of 1835 and the location chosen (a short
distance below the present site of Davenport) near the center
of the county, in order to be sure of the county seat, and at
a place "possessing many advantages." Beautiful lithographs
were sent out to eastern cities to attract prospective
citizens, and the immigrant, who viewed for the first time the
beautiful slope upon which the city was located, thought it
was a paradise indeed. But the unexpected annual overflow of
the Mississippi cut off the " embryo city " from the bluffs by
vast sloughs and mud holes, and this, in connection with the
loss of the county seat alienated its population to such an
extent that it soon sank into an insignificant village. Its
rival, Davenport, continued to grow and prosper and soon began
to contend with Dubuque for the supremacy of the river.
The publication of the
Dubuque Visitor,
the first newspaper in Iowa, in
1836, and the appearance in 1838 of the
Iowa
Sun at Davenport indicated the
substantial nature of the development. The latter paper in its
salutatory professes. that it is the disinterested purpose of
the Sun to " cast its rays; over the -moral and political
landscape, regardless of the petty interests and local
considerations which might contract its beams " However, the
editor takes particular pains to specify that Davenport is "
the center of the system around which all our territorial
interests harmoniously revolve." Both these papers afforded a
much needed means of communication and were of great benefit
in crystallizing the common interests of the people. They also
did great service in bringing Iowa to the attention of the
people of the east.
The introduction of ferries and of more commodious river
boats, as well as the running of public roads throughout the
country very materially improved the facilities for
transportation. This fact tended greatly to augment the number
of immigrants who were constantly seeking homes in the new
country. The river counties filled up very fast and the new
settlers were compelled to go still farther westward.
A space was cleared on the Iowa River in 1839 and in June
of that year, the town of Iowa City was surveyed and the
capital located there, pursuant to an act of Congress which
donated a section of land and $20,000 for the purpose of
erecting buildings. The first sale of lots occurred August
18th of the same year and as the capital of the young
territory, the town made rapid strides in the first few years
of its growths As Professor Shambaugh very aptly says " the
ordinary town has a natural unplanned origin, and grows by
reason of the superior advantages of its location," but with
Iowa City the case was different, for before the sod of the
surrounding county had been turned Iowa City was, with the
exception of Dubuque and Burlington, the most prominent town
in Iowa. In short, Iowa City was a special artificial
creation, deliberately planned and created by the Territory of
Iowa to afford a permanent location for the seat of Government
of the Territory."
When Iowa City was first located it was undoubtedly on
the outer fringe of civilization, but it did not long remain
so. The rush of immigration continued unabated, until by 1841
almost the whole of the territory acquired from the Indians by
the Black Hawk purchase, comprising a strip of country about
fifty miles wide along the Mississippi River, was taken up by
settlers' claims. This fact made it imperatively necessary
that the government should still farther extend the public
domain and this it finally succeeded in doing by acquiring
title to other Indian lands. But before considering the
further westward trend of settlement (which presents many
peculiar phases) and even before we consider more in detail
the religious and social life of the early pioneers, it is
necessary to briefly notice an institution upon which depended
not only the possession of the settlers' land and home, but
which at this early time was practically the only force which
regulated the actions of the community.
IV.
It is very generally conceded that the absence of any
authorized government in frontier settlements was more
beneficial than otherwise. It is true that the wild pioneer
life was very conducive to unrestrained acts of lawlessness,
but in most cases the better class of citizens seem to have "
taken the law into their own hands " and maintained a fair
degree of public order. But more important than this
consideration is the fact that the settlers were left to work
out their own institutions in harmony with the needs of the
time. As Professor Macy has plainly shown, the settlers were
in a better position to shape their own forms of local
government than was Congress, or even their own Territorial
legislature. " The real local institutions of the early
settlers of Iowa are not recorded in any statute-books and
many of the institutions recorded in the statute- books never
had any existence." The early settler was so far away from the
seat of Government, and the laws and legislative provisions
filtered so slowly and vaguely through the wilderness, that he
was practically independent of such remote supervision. When
important acts of the Government which vitally affected the
character of his daily life did reach him, he generally
managed to secure its compliance in harmony- with frontier
custom; and in many cases custom, which was in reality the
common law of the settler, was recognized later by the
Government as rendering the statute inoperative, for the broad
and beaten path of custom leading directly across it (the
statute) had obliterated every apparent vestige of its
existence."" The Claim Association is a very instructive
example which illustrates the working of this principle." When
the Indian title to the Iowa land was extinguished the
settlers who immediately settled thereon believed they had a
perfect right to occupy the land, and that in time they could
secure a valid title from the Government. Prof. Macy has very
clearly shown that "the statute passed in 1807 forbidding
settlements on lands ceded to the United States until
authorized by law" was still unrepealed and that "according to
the letter of the law the settlers in Iowa were subject to
removal, fine and imprisonment. But they were undoubtedly
unconscious lawbreakers, very few even so much as knowing the
statute existed and to these few the fact that it had remained
inoperative for over twenty- five years rendered it
practically void. The unoffending and innocent pioneer
believed he was doing a noble and patriotic service in
reclaiming the wilderness and making it "blossom as the rose."
The energetic settler, although he was entirely oblivious
to the governmental punishment which might at any moment have
descended upon his head, was well aware of the fact that he
had a very insecure hold upon his property. He realized that
he had no legal title, and that when the Government put the
land on sale there was a possibility that someone else might
bid in his claim and thus deprive him of his land with its
valuable improvements. Upon this principle the Claim
Associations were instituted. Each community formed an
Association or Club, with strict " By-Laws" and agreements,
and with the definite object of protecting
bonified
settlers in the possession of
their homes. The main features of; the agreements of these
organizations have been summarized by Prof. Macy as follows:
"(First) There was a provision as to the amount of land
in a 'claim. In some cases this was 480 acres, in others it
was I60 acres. There was sometimes a provision as to what part
should be prairie and what part timber. (Second) There was a
provision as to the amount of improvement required to hold the
claim in cases where the claim was not occupied. (Third) There
was a provision as to occupancy, desertion for a specified
time or a failure to make the required improvement worked
forfeiture. (Fourth) Claims could be sold to any person
approved by the organization, and the buyer had all the
privileges and obligations of the original claimant. A deed
was given and recorded. (fifth) Provisions were made for
settling disputes between claimants....The members of the
organization bound themselves to abide by the decisions of
courts established by the association; or difficulties were
settled in mass meetings; or special arbiters were chosen to
settle special cases; or a neighboring association was invited
to assist in settling a difficulty. In one or other of these
ways nearly all cases were adjusted in an orderly way. (Sixth)
There were provisions for securing the enforcement of all
decisions and for protecting their claims against outside
parties."
In general these provisions seem to have been rigidly
adhered to, but in many cases the requirements were very
liberally interpreted. This was especially true of speculators
who took the claim originally and then sold it to someone else
one writer in describing the scenes among the early settlers
in regard to land claims says, that in reality " a legal
squatter's claim consisted in putting up a shanty or enclosing
a few acres of land with a fence, or breaking prairie, or
blazing on trees if in the grove. This held the claim six
months, then actual residence. Sometimes actual residence
consisted in the squatter taking a blanket and a lunch out to
the claim, and boarding and lodging there an hour or two, and
washing out his dirty stockings. This made a substantial claim
for six months more." This was the exception, however, most of
the settlers being hard-working, frugal, and indefatigable in
the endeavor to improve their farms. It was generally several
years after the settler had secured his claim before the
Government survey was made, and as these surveys divided the
land accurately into townships and sections they played have
with the irregular claims of the settler. The settler found
that his farm was situated on two or perhaps four quarters,
and the difficulties that grew out of these conditions were
innumerable. Honest neighbors easily settled these differences
by deeding to each other the portions of their claims in other
sections, thus equalizing matters by a fair settlement.
Others, not so kindly disposed, were embroiled in the most
bitter controversies. It was here that the arbitration
committee of the association did its best work. This committee
was, in most cases, the court of final instance, and obedience
to its decisions was obligatory. This board and its work is
one of the most important institutions of the period.
It was a part of its duty to see that claims were
properly entered and all requirements fulfilled. This phase of
the work of the committee of adjudication is admirably shown
by the following notice to claimants which appeared in the
Iowa Sun
of March 27, 1839. For we assure
you it will be truly unpleasant for your committee to give
judgment against any of the old friends of this association.
(Signed) RODOLPHUS BENNETT,
JAMES HALL,
THOMAS DILLON,
J. LITCH,
JOSEPH NOLL.
March 16 1839."
During the first few years previous to the
organization of a more definite Territorial Government these
committees acted as the practical judiciary of the country.
They formed the tribunal before which were brought many of the
difficulties which arose in the social life of the community.
Moreover it formed a working police organization. The
committees were boards which were more or less directly
responsible for the public peace. Each member of the
association could be called upon to render assistance in
keeping order as well as in protecting the rightful owners of
claims, and in this manner, all sorts of crimes and offenses
were dealt with. The activities of these Claim Associations
were focused when the time for the land sales drew near. The
government advertised the sale of public lands on a specified
day, and each of the associations had a bidder present who, as
soon as each settler's section was called, bid off the land
for him at the uniform price of $1.25 per acre. Of course
there was a sufficient body of men present from each locality
to add moral force to their claims upon the land, and woe to
the unwary speculator or land shark who attempted to bid
against the recognized claimant. He was promptly knocked down
and hauled out of the way of temptation, and the settler's bid
was thus recognized without opposition.
With the termination of the land sales the settler had a
full legal title to his land, and there being no further need
for the Claim Associations, they died a natural death.
There is one important aspect of this question which
should not be overlooked. In 1839 the Legislature of the
Territory of Iowa passed a law recognizing the neighborhood
customs in regard to claims as legal in actions at law. By
this act the principles involved in the Claim Associations
were given complete legal recognition; and emphasis laid upon
the fact that wise customs
founded upon experience will, in the end, prove to be sound
law.
The selection and retention of claims and the general
subject of land possession gave rise to a large proportion of
the difficulties of pioneer life. "Claim jumping " was
frequently attempted, and the settlers in a body would wait
upon the offender and speedily show him the error of his way.
Whipping, tar and feathers, and other modes of punishment were
frequently resorted to.
Then the difficulties of the claimants themselves often led to
broils and fights and sometimes almost to bloodshed and loss
of life. It is this aspect of the case that has led some to
characterize it as the rule of " mob law." But a careful
consideration of the conditions convinces us that the
difficulties in regard to claims and the Claim Associations,
were grounded in the fundamental social needs of pioneer life.
The whole family life of the settler was bound up in his claim
and in his right was questioned, all the considerations of
self-protection justified him in striking "for his altars and
his fires."
Aside from this we must recognize the fact that the
frontier community is subject to the depredations of
disreputable and lawless characters, who are encouraged by the
knowledge that there is no regular instituted court of justice
or territorial organization of any efficiency. The only way to
deal with such characters is by a just and summary visitation
of punishment for crime. The settler must be his own law-maker
and his own executive, and the self- constituted tribunal is
the main-stay of public order in a pioneer community.
V.
The pioneers are the van-guard of the great army of
progress. Leaving their former homes and friends, they
penetrate the boundless West and there begin the great
struggle of life in the attempt to found a new home in a new
country.
From our earliest childhood we have all been accustomed
to listen to our fathers, grandfathers, and other old
settlers, describe the vivid picture of the hardships and
sufferings of the early pioneer. We have heard of how- they
crossed the trackless prairie; forded streams; braved the
perils of the severest weather; and faced the prowling beast
of prey, as well as endured the troublesome smaller animals.
We have heard of their many encounters with their-uncertain
friends, the Indians, and their thrilling adventures with the
savage red man when he dons his paint and starts upon the war
path We have heard of .the hardships endured when, many miles
away from the nearest trading center, they were deprived of
many of the bare necessities of life; how they had to make
long trips to- have their corn and wheat milled; how the
scarcity of money and the difficulty of getting needed
articles made the most penurious economy, necessary.
All these and many other trials of pioneer life have
become a household story to us all, and it would not only be
the height of presumption to treat them at length here, but it
would indeed be a work of supererogation. We must keep them
well in mind while considering the importance of the social
life of the pioneer settlement, and yet at the same time, we
must also remember that the early settler, looking back upon
these events, is apt to see them through the rosy-hued
spectacles of the present, rather than in their normal
relations. The - subjective element is so strong that the
tendency is to unconsciously add color to the transparent
events of long ago. The fact is that most of the occurrences
which to us seem so vivid and interesting were really rather
prosaic and uneventful. Frontier life, in spite of its perils
and hardships, grew painfully monotonous. Nevertheless, this
strenuous mode of life tended to produce rugged characters.
The daily toil, rendered more difficult by the necessity of
overcoming natural obstacles as well as by the paucity of
working materials, gave the individual a rough and hardy
physique. The usual dreary isolation and monotony, varied only
by occasional flashes of excitement, tended to tinge this
sturdy temperament with touches of fearless abandon, which
often found expression in some form of excitement.
We have already seen that the settlers were very often
engaged in the most bitter controversies over land claims.
Lawlessness and crime, of course, were more or less prevalent
in every community, and it seems to have been assisted in its
work by the presence of liquor shops, which, if we may judge
from the numerous testimonies of old settlers were considered
among the necessities of frontier life. ; The author of "
Davenport Past and Present," in attempting to extenuate this
apparent immorality, says that the old settlers " but complied
with the character of the times, while absent from social
refinements, and the elegance of older towns, almost all
strangers to each other, and craving for that excitement,
which now is indulged in the intercourse of hosts of friends,
and friendly relations of long standing, they could not well
do otherwise than they did. Mostly men from large cities, they
were impressed by the comparative quiet of frontier life, and
to vary their listless lives resorted to stimulants, or
whatever else would afford excitement."
As a demoralizing influence the crude whiskey of the
pioneer undoubtedly occupied an important position, but that
it was more than a contributory cause of many of the
distinctive evils of frontier life would hardly be a
warrantable assumption, especially when we consider the
prominence of the saloon at the present day.
As his desire for excitement often found vent in other
ways. An old settler in describing "Dubuque in Early Times,"
tells of the first public horse-whipping, having occurred in
1833, the first tar and feathering, in 1834, the first
execution by self constituted tribunal in 1834, and the first
elopement in 1835. All these occurred for the first time in
Iowa at Dubuque during the first few years of settlement. The
same author in another article on " Lynch Law at the Dubuque
Mines'' gives a vivid picture of the wrongs often committed
by' this sort of justice. But if we remember that Dubuque was
a mining town, we are prepared to accept these accounts of
lawlessness as one of the necessary adjuncts of that class of
settlements. That it spread, and such scenes were of frequent
occurrence throughout Eastern Iowa, must be candidly admitted;
but to contend that unrestrained acts of violence were so
prevalent as to endanger life and property to any great
extent, would be to distort this element out of all proportion
to its true position. It was only the occasional discord which
sometimes occurs to mar the complete beauty of the symphony.
To counterbalance this we have the widespread influence
of the Claim Associations in adjusting differences and
preserving public order; and also the fact that after 1840,
when the territorial
courts were organized, there was scarcely any work for them to
do and often the session lasted but a few days. Lawlessness
very rapidly decreased and, as the rim of emigration pushed
rapidly westward, much of this undesirable element went with
it.
Social pleasure also occupied a very important place in
frontier life. A few specific instances will best serve to
illustrate its general nature. As an example of social life
upon the extreme border and among the outlying trading-posts,
the following account is interesting. " In our pioneer days
there was not the reserve or restraint in society that there
is today; when our red friends presented us with a pointed
stick, we asked for no explanation, but followed them to their
wigwams and fared sumptuously on dog meat. In winter, whites
and half-breeds mingled in the dance, their favorite dancing
tune being original, was called " Guilmah " or " Stumptail
Dog." Those who did not dance could be found in an adjoining
room engaged at cards; our favorite game was "Bragg," played
with three cards; and one who was so stupid as not to
understand or appreciate its beauties was considered
ineligible to our best society. Horse racing was another great
source of amusement to us; in this sport our red friends were
ever ready to participate, and at times, lost on the result,
every article they possessed on earth."
In the more advanced settlements this class of activities
was somewhat more varied. The author of " Davenport Past and
Present " seems to sum up the testimony of the old settlers
(especially in the river counties) when he says rather
characteristically, " For other amusements, our settlers had
at this period, besides
preachers, steamboat
arrivals, which everybody went down to see; horse racing at
the upper end of-the present site of the city, which all, from
the carpenter on the roof to the merchant behind the counter,
left to witness; sleigh rides to the neighboring places,
followed by a dance, to which all went; balls at home, and
wolf hunts." And the author says further that " social
cast
was not then recognized, and all
went in simply for enjoyment."
Davenport must have gained some renown as a town for
"social enjoyment," for in the
Iowa Sun
of August 25, 1838 we find the
following advertisement which, but for its moderation, would
almost make us believe we were reading one of the flaming
posters of a modern circus.
Good old fashioned "Bees" and
"House Raisings" seem to have been a favorite amusement.
Literary societies, sociables, parties, etc. were very common,
especially among the young people. In these the little church
or school house was the center around which the social life of
the community revolved. Church going was an important item in
the settler's life. If there was no church building, the
services were held in the private cabins whenever a minister
happened that way. These itinerant preachers were gladly
welcomed by the community and many are the settlers who have
testified to the good their visits have done.
The following, from the pen of a hardy old pioneer,
illustrates the attitude toward these preachers on the very
outermost edge of the frontier, the trading-post:—" We had no
church edifice or church members, and when the missionary
visited us, I welcomed him on behalf of the citizens, tendered
him the use of a part of my house for church services, and, in
the capacity of warden, I announced in my bar-room to the
loafers who were to comprise the audience when the time of
services began."
These early churches were often very plain affairs and
very rudely furnished. The following description of one of the
first brick chapels in Davenport gives a good picture of those
primitive structures: " This church was seated at first with
slabs and split saplings, flat side up; and lighted with a
'chandelier' composed of a block of wood suspended by a rope
from the ceiling, in which were inserted some half dozen
tallow candles; and warmed by a stove that looked as though it
might have done good service before the flood." Many, and
indeed most, of the churches in the more remote settlements
were not so elaborate even as this one being simply rough log
houses with the plainest kind of necessary furnishings.
In connection with the work of these pioneer ministers
mention should be made of the " Iowa Band," a devoted company
of twelve theological students from Andover Seminary, who came
out to Iowa and gave their life to the work of God's Kingdom.
The results of their efforts are to be seen in scores of
prospering churches, and in Iowa College, the first college of
the state, which was planned and maintained through their
untiring zeal and devotion.
The limits of this paper have compelled an all too
fragmentary and cursory view of early social conditions, but
it shall have served its purpose if it has revealed the
general nature of pioneer life. Crude this life undoubtedly
was, but this very fact insured its ultimate triumph; In this
early formative period, crudity was an essential element of a
strong and healthy growth. The people may have been rough and
hardy, but they were possessed of an inherent strength of
character and a firm fidelity to purpose.
On the whole, if we take a fair and comprehensive view of
early Iowa society, we must conclude that it was of the better
type. Iowa was settled by people who came mostly from New
England or from territory which had been originally settled by
New Englanders. It would be natural, then, that the ideas
instilled into the Puritan should be transplanted to this far
western soil. No wonder that the church and school grew up
side by side. No wonder that the inborn religious zeal
manifested itself in the social life of the new West. Religion
has plainly shown itself as the inevitable concomitant of the
social life of the people, and these two forces have in turn
been the great factors in giving our western life the purity
and stability which has made the great State of Iowa what it
is.
VI.
With a force as irresistible as a mountain torrent,
the stream of immigration flowed farther and farther westward.
Its advance beyond the point to which we have already traced
it, was, in the main, very similar to its former course. The
experiences of the eastern part of Iowa were repeated in the
western section of the State. The same troubles were
experienced in gaining titles from the Indians and keeping the
settlers off until the old title was fully extinguished. The
same difficulties of settlement were undergone by the settlers
who flocked into the new country. The same social and
religious life accomplished about the same results in the West
as in the East. It was the recurrence of pioneer life in a new
stage under nearly analogous conditions. Yet this further
progress was greatly accelerated by several new factors, and
the new conditions also contain a few peculiar features.
The continual encroachments of the whites were beginning
to arouse the Indians, and their incessant restlessness
breaking out in savage ferocity at the most unexpected times
made increased military activity necessary. This had an
important influence upon the development of the western part
of the State, because it was unsafe for a settler to be very
far away from a military post, and thus the frontier fort
became the nucleus in the formation of settlements. It is
indeed a significant fact that nearly all of the most
important towns in western Iowa were built up in this way.
As early as 1839 the government, having removed the
Pottawattamie Indians from Missouri to southwestern Iowa,
thought it best to watch them rather closely, and so, for that
purpose, erected a fort at what is now Council Bluffs, and
garrisoned it with two companies of United States troops. At
the same time two Catholic missionaries established a mission
there, building rude log huts for themselves and using the
block house of the fort for their meetings. This was, however,
an exceptional case of a fort established well into the
interior for a special purpose, and it was sometime before
regular settlements were made at that place.
In 1843 Fort Des Moines was built at the junction of the
Des Moines and Raccoon Rivers and provided with a garrison of
United States dragoons." Even this was in fact an extreme
frontier outpost as the territory lying north and northwest of
the fort "was comparatively an unexplored region of country,
the habitation of the wild Sioux Indians, and ranges for
buffalo and elk." The settlement of the surrounding country
had not yet really begun, and so, with the exception of
occasional immigrants, very few people succeeded in
penetrating so farmland. This dull sort of existence was
protracted for a decade, and yet, even at the end of that
time, according to the testimony of one pioneer, "independent
of the troops at the fort the population of Polk County was
only about one hundred and fifty souls." Ordinarily this would
not be considered a very desirable journalistic field. but on
July ~6, 1849, the first issue of the
Iowa Star
made its appearance at Fort Des
Moines. A month later the second number was published, and in
this the editor, after explaining that the delay was caused by
the wagoner who was to bring the paper from Keokuk, having
been taken sick, and after having expressed high hopes for the
future, says, " Some have thought this a premature
movement—establishing a weekly newspaper this far out—and
particularly so, to start out with the largest paper in the
state. [They should] remember that this point is the center of
a state nearly as large as all New England, the whole of which
is richer than Holland, and more productive than the famed
alluvions of the ancient Nile." It is a source of
gratification to know that the
Star
realized the buoyant expectations
of its founder and regularly appeared thereafter until it
became a thriving publication in a growing metropolis.
The increasing number of scattered settlers and the
hostility of the Indians rendered a more northern fort
necessary, and in 1849 Fort Dodge was founded and garrisoned.
This was originally called Fort Clark, but the name was
changed in 1851, because the existence of another fort by the
same name made differentiation difficult. In 1853 the troops
were moved north to Fort Ridgely, but the vacated site of the
old fort was purchased and in the first part of the year 1854
a town plot laid out and called Fort Dodge.
During the winter of 1853 the town of Sioux City was
located by some government surveyors, who were attracted by
the beauty of the region around the upper Missouri. The fort
which we have seen was established at the present site of
Council Bluffs did not long remain in commission and was later
abandoned. The old site was reoccupied in rather a peculiar
way. The Mormons, after having been driven out of Illinois,
started to emigrate west, but found it necessary to go into
winter quarters in 1846, after reaching the Missouri. Many of
the adherents of the faith did not move on in the spring but
formed a colony in Pottawattamie County. They founded the town
of Kanesville, which became a Mecca for all of their faith who
travelled westward to the land of promise at Salt Lake City.
It exerted a prominent influence in the affairs of that part
of the state and the Mormons were in entire control. About
1849 the tide of gold seekers, which flowed so incessantly
through the city, attracted gamblers, thugs and all the worst
class of people. This new element was a menace to the peaceful
Mormons and it was not long before they again began their
journey westward to join the colony which had preceded them.
In 1853 the name of Kanesville was changed to Council Bluffs
and the influence of the Mormons practically ceased in western
Iowa.
From 1850 on, the influx of immigrants and settlers
reached enormous proportions. The railroad was an important
element in securing this result. The Rock Island road was
completed as far as the Mississippi, early in I854, and
extended as far as Iowa City by I856. At the same time the
active construction of a road east from Sioux City was
commenced and pushed rapidly forward. The fact that the
settler instead of having to pursue a slow and tedious journey
over the trackless prairie was now brought right to the land
by the railroad was a momentous one in the western
development.
It surfeited the country with claim seekers, and thus
gave rise to a class of speculators and town boomers. The
continual rush of gold seekers on their way to California
tended to augment this condition. Everything was hurry and
excitement and the spirit of speculation ran rife. As one
pioneer says, "During the years of 1856 and 1857 the town
mania ran to an alarming extent among the settlers of the
northwest, while corn and wheat fields were sadly neglected.
Very many good quarter sections were spoiled by being driven
full of stakes and gorgeously-displayed on paper, while the
only perceptible improvements-were the aforementioned stakes
and the only citizens gophers, who held the lots by right of
possession, and who seriously objected to having their range
intercepted by cottonwood stakes. Few out of the many of those
paper towns proved a success."
But these manifestations were only temporary, and after
the Indians had been finally pacified and after the
demoralizing effect of inflated speculation had been worked
off, the country settled down again to its normal condition of
gradual development.
After having considered very briefly these activities
which seem to have had special significance in western
development, it is still plain that they have little value
aside from the movement as a whole. It is one continuous
expansion, a pushing over from one section into another, and
it is this essential unity which makes so potent the organic
development of the state. By 1860 this real formative period
was practically completed and Iowa stood a strong, well
equipped state, willing and able to hold her own in the
battles that were to come.
VII.
We have thus brought our sketch of early Iowa social
conditions down to the point where maturity begins. The
structural formation is now complete and the normal state
enters upon a period of purely strengthening and perfecting
growth. Although these early stages have been purely
experimental we must conclude that, on the whole, as
experiments they have been eminently successful. They may have
swung from one extreme to the other and at times trembled on
the verge of failure, but, taken collectively and with
reference to their essential contribution to history, it is
evident that they have formed a basis sufficiently firm and
enduring to stand the weight of succeeding institutions.
Our aim has been to show the true nature of these early
experimental stages and to trace the main historical movements
that run like threads of gold throughout the complicated web
of social life. The attempt has not aimed to be exhaustive but
merely suggestive, and it will, perhaps, call attention to the
vast storehouse of historical material which lies ready for
the hand of the future historian.
* "The Significance of the Frontier in American History, "
by Professor Frederick J. Turner of the University of
Wisconsin. Annual Report of the American Historical
Association, 1893, pp.200-201.
** William Roscoe Thayer, Dawn of Italian Independence,
Vol. I, p. 348 |